Shop

  • Make any meal special with the rich taste of pumpkin pie. Made with never canned ingredients, our light flaky crust is filled with smooth, delicious pumpkin and a blend of warm spices and brown sugar. Our limited edition Pumpkin Pie has all the quality and goodness you expect from Village PieMaker!
  • Luscious. Fragrant. Authentic. Our Apple Pie showcases a light and fluffy, butter casing generously layered with sweet, ripe Granny Smith apples. With a succulent, orchard-sized taste, this  American staple is always a family favorite.
  • It’s like instant summer to brighten your day. There’s no substitute for the amount of love we put into this pie. From the plump, ripe blueberries to the light, buttery handmade crust, it’s overflowing with sunshine and happiness. Slice up a generous serving of smiles and share.
  • Red, ripe, and true. This gourmet pie reminds us that Apple isn’t the only all-American favorite in town. Bright, fragrant, fruit filling cradled in our handmade buttery crust is delicious straight out of the oven, with a scoop of old fashioned vanilla ice cream, or as a late-night snack.
  • Not just a fan favorite, but one of our favorites as well. Sweet strawberries and tart rhubarb is a tantalizing match made in heaven. This perfect flavor combination is always ready to meet you for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Cloaked in our buttery hand-crimped crust, this delectable pie is always dressed for the occasion.
  • Complex! Chewy! These over-the-top cookie gems gleefully join decadent chocolate and crunchy pecans in a marriage of sophisticated elegance. Perfect for hostess gifts.  
  • Complex! Chewy! These over-the-top cookie gems gleefully join decadent chocolate and crunchy pecans in a marriage of sophisticated elegance. Perfect for hostess gifts.  
  • Complex! Chewy! These over-the-top cookie gems gleefully join decadent chocolate and crunchy pecans in a marriage of sophisticated elegance. Perfect for hostess gifts.
  • Chocolate Chip Cream ButterHearts® ButterHearts are made from delicious, artisan-style puff pastry. Each pastry has hundreds of thin layers of pastry goodness, making them a melt-in-your-mouth experience every time! They are gooey and sticky in the package, but delicious out of the oven. Each 23.5-ounce package of ButterHearts contains 12 servings and includes two icing packets for a little extra sweetness!
  • Classic Sugar ButterHearts® ButterHearts are made from delicious, artisan-style puff pastry. Each pastry has hundreds of thin layers of pastry goodness, making them a melt-in-your-mouth experience every time! They are gooey and sticky in the package, but delicious out of the oven. Each 23.5-ounce package of ButterHearts contains 12 servings and includes two icing packets for a little extra sweetness!
  • Raspberry Cream ButterHearts® ButterHearts are made from delicious, artisan-style puff pastry. Each pastry has hundreds of thin layers of pastry goodness, making them a melt-in-your-mouth experience every time! They are gooey and sticky in the package, but delicious out of the oven. Each 23.5-ounce package of ButterHearts contains 12 servings and includes two icing packets for a little extra sweetness!
  • Cinnamon

    $17.00
    Magically form a heart while in the oven with delicious cinnamon sugary, buttery filling in every bite. Each package contains 12 servings and frosting packet.
Go to Top